(copied my comment from the original post... didn't realize there was a forum, hehe)
So I was talking to a friend about games we played growing up, and we realized that for some reason we both had games in our favorites that often appear on others' "Worst Games of All Time" lists. Like for me, when I was 10, I loved the NES version of Who Framed Roger Rabbit (which is also to this day still my favorite film, too). I played the HELL out of that game, even beating Judge Doom without a Game Genie, yet I apparently had no idea that I wasn't supposed to like it, lol.
How about you guys? What games do you remember playing and loving as a kid, only to find out later on down the road... holy crap, that game sucked??